Skip to content

Article

The UN can decide next week to end bottom trawling on high-seas seamounts. Will it?

Russ

By Russell Moffitt | October 28, 2026

The UN can decide next week to end bottom trawling on high-seas seamounts. Will it?

Over twenty years ago, the UN told nations to “consider” protecting the deep sea from bottom trawling. Starting October 29 in New York, governments can finally commit to a 2027 deadline. Anything less is the same failure in new words.

In February 2004, Marine Conservation Institute released a statement signed by 1,136 scientists from 69 countries. They asked the United Nations for one thing: a moratorium on bottom trawling on the high seas. That same year, our founder Dr. Elliott Norse stood at UN headquarters alongside the newly formed Deep Sea Conservation Coalition (DSCC) and made the case in person.

The General Assembly’s answer that November was to urge nations to “consider” interim bans. Two years later, Resolution 61/105 told States to protect seamounts, cold-water corals, and other vulnerable marine ecosystems from destructive fishing “immediately.”

Matthew Gianni of the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition, addresses a press conference on bottom trawl fishing in international waters. Elliott Norse, President of the Marine Conservation Institute on left. Photo: UN Photo | Mark Garten
Actress Sigourney Weaver briefs journalists on the destruction caused to oceans by high seas bottom trawling at the 2006 Press Conference sponsored by the United Nations Environment Programme, at UN Headquarters in New York. Photo: UN Photo | Mark Garten

That was twenty years ago. Bottom trawlers are still dragging nets across seamounts in international waters.

From October 29 to November 6, governments are meeting in New York to negotiate this year’s UN Sustainable Fisheries Resolution. This one is different. It closes the formal 2026 review of whether States and regional fishery bodies have actually done what they promised. This year there is a deadline on the table.

The proposal

A proposal now before the UN General Assembly would add two short paragraphs to the resolution. The first paragraph states plain concern about the ongoing evidence of significant harm from bottom trawling on seamounts. The second calls on States, on their own and through regional fisheries bodies, to protect seamounts by “phasing out bottom trawl fishing on seamounts in areas beyond national jurisdiction by no later than 31 December 2027.”

That is the whole ask. Several countries have already signaled support. More need to say so out loud before November 6.

The evidence is not in dispute

The high seas cover nearly two-thirds of the ocean, yet remains some of the least protected waters on Earth. Seamounts and knolls cover roughly a fifth of the seafloor worldwide — about 74 million square kilometers, an area comparable to Asia and Africa combined — and nearly a quarter of the seafloor on the high seas. Their slopes are home to coral and sponge communities that have grown over centuries (sometimes millennia), and they serve as anchors for feeding grounds and migration routes for sharks, turtles, whales, tunas, and seabirds. A trawl net destroys those structures in a single pass.

The high seas cover nearly two-thirds of the ocean, yet remains some of the least protected waters on Earth. The slopes of seamounts are home to coral and sponge communities that have grown over centuries (sometimes millennia), and they serve as anchors for feeding grounds and migration routes for sharks, turtles, whales, tunas, and seabirds. A trawl net destroys those structures in a single pass.

As Dr. Elin Angharad Thomas of the Deep-Ocean Stewardship Initiative (DOSI) and the University of Western Australia, laid out in The Conversation this week, with contributions from Dr. Lissette Victorero, the gear is enormous: nets 80 to 200 meters wide, held open by metal doors weighing up to five metric tons. Scientists have yet to find a seamount that fully recovered after trawling stopped, even 40 years later. And the kicker? Only about 1.5% of known seamounts on the high seas are protected today.

This is not only the science community’s assessment of the situation. The UN’s own Second World Ocean Assessment named bottom trawling the greatest current threat to seamount ecosystems, and this year’s Third Assessment again calls it the most significant human activity on the deep continental margins (WOA II 2021; WOA III 2026). The Secretary-General’s 2026 report documents significant adverse impacts from bottom trawling and calls it a particularly destructive fishing method (UN Secretary-General 2026, paras. 30, 35). Evidence presented at the UN’s Bottom Fisheries Workshop in July showed that two decades of measures have not stopped the damage.

Those measures were always going to struggle. “Move-on” rules ask a trawler to relocate after it has already hauled up coral. Impact assessments are prepared by the fishing States themselves, often with their own industry in the room. Closures cover only a sliver of the seamounts at risk. Twenty years of incremental management has produced twenty years of compounding loss.

There is a deeper flaw. Under most regional fishery rules, a seamount is protected only after surveys or bycatch begin to turn up enough coral or sponge to label the area as a “vulnerable marine ecosystem” (VME). But since 2006, the General Assembly has listed seamounts by name as one of the vulnerable marine ecosystems States must protect — not just the corals and sponges found on them. A seamount should not have to prove its biodiversity value one haul at a time.

The recovery studies to date point one way. Trawling a seamount causes significant adverse impacts every time; it is not a risk that careful management can avoid (Baco et al. 2020; UN Secretary-General’s 2026 report, paras. 30–31, DSCC SAI Policy Brief). Rules that allow seamount trawling on the condition that it causes no significant harm set a bar no trawler can clear.

Orange roughy caught while spawning. Trawlers target the fish both in breeding aggregations above seamounts and in their deep-sea habitat. © Greenpeace | Kim Westerskov
Degraded seamount habitats affected by bottom trawling (A: Morgue Seamount, B: Yuryaku Seamount) and healthy, unimpacted coral communities (C: Gothic Seamount, D: Koko Seamount). Adapted from Clark and Rowden (2009), Baco et al. (2019)
Crewmen on the New Zealand bottom trawler, Waipori, dump a large piece of Paragorgia coral dredged from the deep sea in their net. © Greenpeace | Malcolm Pullman

Everyone else has already moved

Over the past year, the world has said yes to protection, resoundingly:

  • In October 2025, the IUCN World Conservation Congress adopted Resolution 8.032, calling on governments to support and activate a transition away from seamount trawling at this year’s UN General Assembly review. 95% of voting State members backed it.
  • In March 2026, the 133 parties to the Convention on Migratory Species adopted a resolution (Decision 15.61) to prioritize protecting seamounts from overfishing and destructive practices.
  • The BBNJ Agreement, also known as the “High Seas Treaty” is now in force, and States that ratified it are obligated to align fisheries management with biodiversity protection.
  • More than 400 scientists have signed the Seamount Scientists Proclamation, which Marine Conservation Institute launched with the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition and the International Programme on the State of the Ocean at the 2025 UN Ocean Conference.
  • Public pressure is building, too. Bottom trawling was long out of sight, out of mind — until David Attenborough’s film Ocean showed millions of viewers what a trawl does to the seafloor, and left many of them shocked that it’s still allowed anywhere.

Bottom trawling was long out of sight and out of mind - until David Attenborough’s film Ocean showed millions of viewers exactly what a trawl does to the seafloor, and left many of them shocked that it’s still allowed anywhere.

The legal footing is just as solid. International law doesn’t just permit a phase-out; arguably it demands one, under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, the UN Fish Stocks Agreement, and the High Seas Treaty.

The only obstacle is political

In 2022, the General Assembly asked for the obstacles to implementing its commitments to be identified. Four years on, the answer is plain. It is not a lack of science, legal authority, or monitoring tools. It is States refusing to take the action they already committed to.

Only a handful of countries still send vessels to trawl seamounts on the high seas. The catch is small, and the fleets are small. What protects the practice is not science, law, or sound economics - high-seas bottom trawling in many regions has long depended on government subsidies to stay afloat (Sumaila et al. 2010; Sala et al. 2018). It is the habit of negotiators treating “continue to monitor” and “encourage further efforts” as acceptable outcomes.

They are not acceptable anymore. Another resolution that “notes progress” and schedules another review would be business as usual dressed up as diplomacy. It would tell the world that two decades of UN commitments - reinforced by the Global Biodiversity Framework, the IUCN vote, the CMS decision, and the High Seas Treaty - count for nothing the minute governments put industry objections or future fishing ambitions ahead of the science.

This week is a test of whether those commitments mean anything - or whether fisheries talks will stay walled off from the biodiversity promises the same governments make everywhere else. The timing could not be more pointed. Negotiations open as CBD COP17 in Yerevan wraps up the first global review of how countries are implementing the Global Biodiversity Framework (GBF). Implementation is the whole point - and here is a ready-made chance to deliver it. 

KMGBF-Logo-1-bigger

Setting and achieving a single deadline to end seamount trawling would advance at least half a dozen of the Global Biodiversity Framework (GBF) targets at once: protecting 30% of the ocean (Target 3), halting species loss (Target 4), sustainable use of wild species and fisheries (Targets 5 and 10), keeping the loss of high-biodiversity areas close to zero (Target 1), and building climate resilience (Target 8).

The GBF review has an uncomfortable answer. By the count of Marine Conservation Institute’s Marine Protection Atlas (mpatlas.org), only 3.5% of the ocean is both implemented and fully or highly protected - even though about 10% has been designated as protected at some level. The sad truth is that too much protection exists on paper and nowhere else. Next week’s decision is a chance to make protection real on the water, whereas failure to agree would reinforce an all-too-familiar contradiction: governments commit to reversing biodiversity loss while simultaneously allowing the activities driving it to continue in some of the ocean’s most vulnerable ecosystems.

In January, governments will open the first conference of parties for the High Seas Treaty. Its protected areas will only work if fisheries bodies cooperate. How States handle seamounts during the UNGA Resolution negotiations is the first real test.

What we are asking

Marine Conservation Institute calls on every government at the table to support the proposed phase-out in full - including the 2027 deadline - and to resist any attempt to soften it into language that “considers” or “encourages.”

We have heard “consider” before. In 2004, it cost us two decades.

We have been fighting for these places since our founding thirty years ago. Seamounts are among the wildest ocean places left on Earth. They should not be lost to inertia.

About Marine Conservation Institute

Marine Conservation Institute is a nonprofit organization working to secure permanent, strong protection for the ocean's most important places for us and future generations. Learn more at https://marine-conservation.org/.